Is Ollie Fresh Pet Food Good for My Dog?

Published: 01/15/2021
Ollie Fresh Pet Food is a pet food subscription service that delivers healthy pet food right to your door. Provide some information about your pup to receive a bespoke meal plan with portions customized to your dog’s daily recommended intake.

Formulated in partnership with veterinary nutritionists, Ollie promises its food is safe enough even for humans to eat. A cursory glance at the ingredients list confirms the company uses only the freshest foods — no byproducts or fillers.

Thinking about switching Sparky over to Ollie Fresh Pet Food? We’ve dug up the deets so you don’t have to! Read our unbiased review to discover how Ollie Fresh Pet Food works, how much it costs, ingredients and nutrition facts, and more.

Overview

Ollie Fresh Pet Food is a little different than other dog foods on the market. You won’t find it on the shelves of your local pet store — instead, you’ll order Fido’s food on the Ollie Fresh Pet Food website. Four recipes are available through Ollie: Hearty Beef Eats, Healthy Turkey Feast, Chicken Goodness, and Tasty Lamb Fare. 

This subscription service delivers frozen food packets to your door according to the schedule you set. The default shipping schedule is once every 8 weeks, but you can customize delivery frequency in your MyOllie account.

To get started, provide your name and email address, then provide a few details about your pup, including their:

  • Name

  • Age

  • Gender

  • Breed

  • Current weight

  • Ideal weight (optional)

  • Spay/neuter status

  • Body type: Lean, ideal, round

  • Activity level: Not very active, pretty active, hyper

  • Current food (dry, wet, raw, etc.)

  • Allergies

After providing these details, you’ll receive a custom meal plan complete with portions tailored to your dog’s unique nutritional needs. On this screen, you can choose which recipes you’d like to order, adjust your dog’s daily portion size, view ingredients lists and nutrition facts, and read answers to FAQs.

When you receive your order, you’ll need to refrigerate it by midnight on the same day. Once refrigerated, Ollie recipes stay good for 4 days (opened and unopened). Ollie food is freezer-safe, too. Just defrost your pup’s food in the refrigerator for at least 24 hours before serving!

Cost

The cost of Ollie Fresh Pet Food depends on the quantity and recipe(s) you choose, as well as your pet’s meal plan. At the time of writing, new customers get 20% off their first 2-week starter box order, which comes with 14 packs of food, a pet food storage container and scoop, and a custom feeding guide. First responders and medical personnel receive a 50% discount on their first 3 boxes, but must provide ID verification.

According to the Ollie website, the cost of food for a small dog starts at $3 per day. We went through the motions of signing up for a 2-week starter box for a 5-year old, 20 lb. female spayed dog whose breed was unknown. Here are the prices Ollie quoted us:

  • Hearty Beef Eats: $21.59/week with discount ($26.99 full price)

  • Healthy Turkey Feast: $24.83/week with discount ($31.04 full price)

  • Chicken Goodness: $24.46/week with discount ($28.07 full price)

  • Tasty Lamb Fare: $24.40/week ($30.50 full price)

  • All 4 recipes: $23.32/week ($29.15 full price)

These prices were for a 100% daily portion of Ollie food. If your pup eats smaller portions, you’ll pay less. Shipping is free, so the price you see at checkout is the price you get!

Age
Ollie’s custom recipes are suitable for dogs of all ages, including puppies. All of Ollie’s recipe’s meet the Association of American Feed Control Officials’ (AAFCO) regulations for nutrient profiles for all life stages.
Breeds
Because Ollie’s meal plans are customized for your dog’s nutritional needs, they’re suitable for all breeds, even large dogs over 70 pounds.
Ingredients

Ollie is transparent about the quality of its ingredients and food preparation policies. The company sources meat from human-grade and free-range farms across the US and Australia.

Cooked at low temperatures in small batches, each recipe is hand-packed at Ollie’s New Jersey facility and shipped in regular intervals based on the pet parent’s delivery schedule.

The ingredients vary depending on the recipe. Here’s an overview of the ingredients used in Ollie’s recipes. (Please note this may not be a complete list. For more information, review the ingredients list of the dog food you’re interested in purchasing.)

Meat/Dairy:

Beef, beef heart, beef kidney, beef liver, turkey breast, turkey liver, chicken, chicken gizzard, chicken liver, lamb, lamb liver, whole dried eggs

Vegetables/Fruit/Grains:

Sweet potatoes, peas, carrots, kale, butternut squash, spinach, lentils, pumpkin, blueberries, cranberries, potatoes, chickpeas, rice

Oils:

Fish oil, cod liver oil, coconut oil

Seasoning:

Iodized salt, basil, rosemary, chia seeds

Nutrition Facts

The nutrition facts vary based on which recipe you choose and your dog’s nutritional needs. Ollie listed the following nutrition facts on recipes for a 5-year-old, 20 lb. female spayed dog whose breed was unknown.

Hearty Beef Eats:

  • Calories: 1540 kcal ME/kg

  • Protein: 9% (minimum)

  • Fat: 7% (minimum)

  • Fiber: 2% (maximum)

  • Moisture: 70% (maximum)

Healthy Turkey Feast:

  • Calories: 1390 kcal ME/kg

  • Protein: 11% (minimum)

  • Fat: 7% (minimum)

  • Fiber: 2% (maximum)

  • Moisture: 72% (maximum)

Chicken Goodness:

  • Calories: 1298 kcal ME/kg

  • Protein: 10% (minimum)

  • Fat: 3% (minimum)

  • Fiber: 2% (maximum)

  • Moisture: 73% (maximum)

Tasty Lamb Fare:

  • Calories: 1804 kcal ME/kg

  • Protein: 10% (minimum)

  • Fat: 7% (minimum)

  • Fiber: 2% (maximum)

  • Moisture: 74% (maximum)

Ratings

Ollie Fresh Pet Food boasts glowing reviews from pet parents, veterinarians, and major news outlets alike. Dog Food Advisor gives Ollie a flawless 5-star review.

Positive reviews from pet parents mention improved digestion, fewer allergies, less itching, and healthier coat. Many pet parents also said their dogs loved the taste of the food. Less enthusiastic reviews cited cost and delivery and customer service issues.

Is Ollie Fresh Pet Food right for my dog?

While there’s no doubt Ollie uses fresh ingredients from human-grade farms, every dog has different nutritional needs. What might improve one dog’s coat could upset another’s stomach. When transitioning your pup to a new dog food, be sure to take it slow.

Got questions or concerns about your doggo’s diet? Chat with a vet now to discuss your dog’s nutritional needs.

Book me a walkiee?
Pweeeze!
Sketch of smiling australian shepherd