Best Organic Dog Food 2024

Written by Jasmine Sawatzky

Veterinary reviewed by:

Published: 05/02/2023, edited: 02/08/2024

The Wag! team conducts independent research and consults pet experts to curate our recommendations. This content is supported by our affiliate pet partners and we may receive a commission on the links provided.

Organic foods have become increasingly popular among humans, and even their fur babies! This is for good reason as organic food must be grown and farmed without artificial chemicals, hormones, antibiotics, and genetically modified organisms. These foods need to meet strict USDA guidelines to qualify as organic. Unfortunately, it can be difficult to find certified organic dog food. That’s where we come in!

Before you start shopping for organic dog food, it's important to know what your dog's nutritional requirements are. This will depend on factors like their age, size, activity level, and health status. Consult with your veterinarian to determine the right balance of protein, fat, carbohydrates, and other nutrients that your dog needs.

You’ll also want to check the label for organic certification from a reputable organization and check the ingredient list. It should be transparent and easy to understand. Look for real, whole-food ingredients such as meat, vegetables, and grains, and avoid foods that contain by-products, fillers, and any artificial preservatives.

Here are some of the top organic dog foods that meet our approval!

Ollie

Best organic subscription service

Ollie is a subscription-based organic dog food service offering fresh and kibble options. Their ingredients are carefully sourced, and their recipes are manufactured in USDA-approved kitchens. Plus, they undergo rigorous quality checks, including batch-testing and scans for foreign matter. They also vacuum-seal and insulate their packages to ensure they are fresh as paws-ible when they arrive on your doorstep.

We have researched the gamut of food subscription services, and we’re super impressed with how customizable Ollie is compared to similar brands.

Ollie makes it easy to switch delivery days and allows you to mix and match dry and fresh foods. It even offers half portions for people to mix in their pet’s current kibble for a more budget-friendly option.

Ollie fresh food varieties:

Beef Dish with Sweet Potatoes
Chicken Dish with Carrots
Turkey Dish with Blueberries
Lamb Dish with Cranberries
Pork Dish with Apples

Ollie baked food varieties:

Baked Beef with Sweet Potatoes
Baked Chicken with Carrots

Ollie Dog Food

Editor's Choice

Shop on Ollie Shop on Petco

Why Wag! Loves It

Suitable for all life stages
Lasts up to 6 months in the freezer
Customizable plans allow you to switch up your recipes, portion sizes, and delivery days to best suit your pet’s lifestyle.
Their starter box offer allows you to try their recipes at a heavily discounted rate (and they even guarantee their products, so if you’re not satisfied with the recipes, they will refund you!)

Considerations & Concerns

Must be dilligent with storage since it is a fresh food.
Will only last 4 days in the fridge after thawing
Fresh food subscriptions like Ollie are more expensive than commercial kibble

What pet parents say about Ollie

“This is excellent, high-quality food. Possibly the best I’ve ever tried. My one year-old Chihuahua has thin patchy fur from a fungal infection she had before she was rescued. After switching to Ollie, her coat came in full, thick, and gorgeous. It shocked me and I looked up the reviews on the food and saw that other people had said that it grew fur! Thoroughly impressed.”

“The delivery is prompt and the food comes well packaged and chilled. Giorgio loves all the flavors and he has finished his plate every day for the past month. His coat looks so shiny and he put on the little bit of weight he needed (he was a bit underweight and now he’s perfect). He has tons of energy and doesn’t have upset stomach or problems with his stools. We love Ollie!”

Gather Dog Food

Petcurean's Gather product line is a fantastic choice for pet owners who want to give their doggos the best nutrition possible. This line is made with certified organic and sustainably sourced ingredients, including fruits, vegetables, and protein-rich meats. The result is a delicious and wholesome meal that is free from artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. With such a commitment to sustainability and quality, you can feel good about feeding your pet this exceptional line of dog food.

Gather dog food varieties:

Free Acres Organic Free-Run Chicken
Endless Valley Vegan

Gather Dog Food

Up to 35% off with Chewy Autoship

Why Wag! Loves It

Contains high-quality ingredients.
Contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives.
Has limited ingredients, great for dogs with sensitive stomachs.
Is environmentally conscious.

Considerations & Concerns

Can be more expensive than other brands.
May not be as widely available as other brands.
Has a strong scent some people and pups might not love.

What pet parents say about Gather

“My dog Daisy has a sensitive stomach and has been having all sorts of problems due to her food that she didn’t even like. I switched her to this food and she has made a 180 turn around for the better. I’m very happy with this product.”

Tender & True Organic Dog Food

4.5

Tender and True’s organic dog food line is one of the few dog food lines out there that are USDA-certified organic. Made with only the highest quality organic ingredients, Tender and True is a great choice for pet owners who want to feed their dogs a natural and wholesome diet. Free from artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors, this dog food is packed with essential nutrients and is gentle on your dog's digestive system.

Tender and True cares about more than just your dog's tummy. It’s also committed to sustainability, using eco-friendly packaging and sourcing ingredients from trusted farmers and suppliers.

Tender & True Organic dog food flavors:

Small breed organic chicken recipe
Organic chicken and liver recipe
Organic turkey and liver recipe

Tender & True treats:

Organic Turkey Grain-Free Jerky Dog Treats
Organic Beef Grain-Free Jerky Dog Treats
Organic Chicken Grain-Free Jerky Dog Treats
Organic Pork Recipe with Organic Apple Jerky Dog Treats

Tender and True Organic Dog Food

Editor's Choice

Up to 35% off with Chewy Autoship Shop on Petco

Why Wag! Loves It

Has never had a product recall.
Is supplemented with chelated minerals for optimal nutrient absorption.
Does not contain fillers, by-products, or artificial additives.

Considerations & Concerns

Has low protein content.
Is high in carbohydrates.
Is low in moisture.
Contains plant-based proteins.

What pet parents say about Tender and True Organic

“This is the only food I feed my dog. We both love it! I'm so happy to have an organic dog food made of high quality ingredients to feed my dog. It's very important to me to feed my dog organic food because non-organic dog foods have lots of bad chemicals and pesticides in them. This organic dog food is the best! My dog eats it happily. I will add... my dog is very regular and has healthy poop when eating this food, too. Highly recommend!”

Primal Freeze-Dried Nuggets Dog Food

Best for raw diets

With Primal’s Freeze-Dried Nuggets for Dogs, your pup can enjoy the benefits of a raw diet without the hassle and mess. Best of all, Primal is made with certified organic fruits and vegetables. The meat is fresh, hormone and antibiotic-free whole muscle meat, organ meat, and meaty bones.

Primal Freeze-Dried Nuggets flavors:

Beef
Chicken
Duck
Lamb
Pork
Rabbit
Turkey and sardine
Venison

Primal Freeze-Dried Nuggets Dog Food

Up to 35% off with Chewy Autoship

Why Wag! Loves It

Made with high-quality ingredients.
Is convenient to store and transport.
Has a long shelf-life
Can improve your dog's digestion.
Comes in a wide range of flavors.

Considerations & Concerns

Can be more expensive than other dog foods.
Needs to be rehydrated before feeding.
Has a risk of contamination, as with any raw food products.

What pet parents say about Primal Freeze-Dried Nuggets

“We have been using Primal Freeze Dried Chicken for years now. It is not the main dog food (too expensive for my large breeds) but each dog gets a nugget or two crushed up on top of their food per meal. Even my most picky eater will eat their food with this on top. I have recommended it to many people over the years for their picky dogs and it has always been a hit.”

FAQ

What is organic dog food?

Organic dog food is made from ingredients that are grown and processed without synthetic fertilizers, pesticides, antibiotics, hormones, or GMOs. Organic ingredients used in dog food must be certified by an organic certification agency to ensure they meet strict standards.

Is organic dog food worth it?

Whether or not organic dog food is worth it ultimately depends on the individual pet parent’s priorities and budget. Organic dog food is generally considered to be a healthier and more natural alternative to conventional dog food, because it’s free from harmful chemicals and additives. However, it can be less affordable for some pet owners.

If you prioritize providing your dog with the highest quality, natural, and nutritious diet possible, and have the budget to afford it, organic dog food may be worth the investment.

How does Wag! determine paw ratings for dog food?

Our editorial team conducts independent research when choosing which foods to feature and how to rate them. Our paw ratings are largely based on the ingredients and nutritional content of each food. Here’s a quick guide to what our paw ratings mean:

1 paw: High filler content, meat not listed as first ingredient
2 paws: Meat meal, bone meal or meat by-products listed as first ingredient
3 paws: Named meat listed as first ingredient (e.g., chicken); AAFCO approved
4 paws: Same as 3 paws, but also made with whole, limited ingredients and minimal processing
5 paws: Same as 4 paws, but is also veterinarian or veterinary body approved and includes human-grade ingredients
Half-paws may be awarded for extra benefits, like affordability, trustworthiness, etc.