Gather Cat Food Review 2025

Home
Pet Product Reviews
Cat Food
Gather Cat Food Review 2025

4.5

Written by Adam Lee-Smith

Veterinary reviewed by:

Published: 08/01/2024, edited: 02/27/2025

The Wag! team conducts independent research and consults pet experts to curate our recommendations. This content is supported by our affiliate pet partners and we may receive a commission on the links provided.

Overview

Gather cat food product ranges and flavors
Why Wag! likes Gather cat food
Concerns & considerations
What pet parents say about Gather cat food
Gather cat food history
Gather cat food recalls
FAQ

Gather cat food is an excellent choice if you're an environmentally conscious pet parent on the hunt for a high-quality kibble for your feline friend.

Made with certified organic ingredients and USDA-approved free-run chicken, Gather is the real deal. And Gather doesn't stop there with its sustainability — 97% of its office's energy is from renewable sources, and its packaging is made from 30% plant material.

We highly rate Gather cat food due to its overall quality, sustainable practices, and transparent ingredient sourcing. However, Gather loses a few points for its lack of recipe variety and high carb levels.

Keep reading for a comprehensive Gather cat food review, where we deep dive into benefits, recalls, customer reviews, and more!

Interested in feeding your cat organic cat food? Check out our round-up of the best organic cat foods in 2025!

Gather cat food product ranges and flavors

Gather focuses on quality over quantity — it produces only one dry cat food recipe.

Gather Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats is "complete and balanced," meeting the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) nutrient profile guidelines of maintenance (adults).

Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats

Gather Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats is made with no animal by-products, meat meals, or GMO ingredients. The top two ingredients in this recipe are organic chicken and organic dehydrated chicken.

Gather adds organic produce to its cat food recipe for a nutrient boost. Flaxseed is a source of omega-6 fatty acids, while cranberries are high in antioxidants. Eggshell meal is an excellent source of calcium and other minerals like selenium, magnesium, and strontium.

One of the main downsides of Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats is that peas and lentils are among its top five ingredients.

As a result, this recipe contains over 40% carbohydrates, which is above-average for dry cat food. Many experts say no more than 30% of a cat's calories should come from carbohydrates.

Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats has higher than average fat levels (17.8%), meaning it's not the best choice for overweight cats.

Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats contains 33.3% dry protein matter, which is average for dry cat food.

Why Wag! likes Gather cat food

Here are just some of the reasons we give Gather cat food a near-flawless 4.5 out of 5 paws up!

Organic ingredients

The chicken, peas, and flaxseed used in Gather cat food are 100% certified organic. However, Gather doesn't state whether the cranberries and blueberries used in its cat food are certified organic.

The USDA regulates certified organic accreditations. To be certified organic, a company must use only natural fertilizers in its crops, no growth hormones or antibiotics in its meat, and no GMOs in its packaged goods.

A certified organic accreditation means you're getting one of the highest-quality products possible, made using environmentally friendly and sustainable practices.

Transparent ingredient sourcing

Gather is one of the most transparent pet food companies we've encountered regarding ingredient sourcing. Its website lists farms, co-ops, and companies from which it sources its ingredients.

For example, its peas, lentils, and seed oils come from the Farmer Direct Co-Op in Saskatchewan, Canada. Its chicken comes from Miller Poultry, based in Orland, Indiana. As a result, you can be confident about the quality and origin of the ingredients in your cat's food.

Environmentally-friendly practices

In addition to producing premium cat food, Gather employs environmentally friendly business practices to help protect the planet.

As mentioned, 97% of Gather's office power comes from renewable energy sources, while its packaging is 30% plant-based. Plus, Gather works to promote equality in its workplace—67% of Gather's senior management are women.

Concerns & considerations

Thinking Gather cat food might be right for your feline friend? Let's check out a few things to consider before you buy!

Less affordable than some alternatives

Gather cat food is a bit pricier than some alternative organic cat foods. At the time of writing, an 8-lb bag of Gather Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats costs $54.59 on Chewy, which works out to $6.83 per lb.

In comparison, a 7-lb bag of Tender & True Organic Chicken & Liver Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food costs $34.32 on Chewy, which works out to $4.91 per lb.

Above-average carbs and fat

Gather Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe for Adult Cats contains 17.8% fat and over 40% carbs, above average for dry cat food.

While these fat and carb levels aren't an issue for a healthy adult cat, they may mean that Gather cat food isn't the best choice for cats with health problems like obesity and diabetes mellitus.

Only one recipe available

Gather only offers one chicken dry food for cats. As a result, Gather cat food isn't suitable for cats with a chicken allergy.

Plus, according to AAFCO nutrient profile guidelines, Gather Organic Free-Run Chicken Recipe is only suitable for adults. You'll need to pick a different cat food for a kitten or pregnant feline.

What pet parents say about Gather cat food

"My cats loved this food immediately, and weeks later now, still love it. I love it because of the ingredients and quality. Even the packaging is A+. Their overall health seems to be improving already."

"My cats are definite food snobs and so far they love it. It's only been a week, but I've seen no allergy issues or upset tummys."