- Home
- Best Products
- Cat Food
- Best Organic Cat Food 2024
Best Organic Cat Food 2024
Written by Adam Lee-Smith
Veterinary reviewed by:
Published: 03/30/2024, edited: 03/30/2024
The Wag! team conducts independent research and consults pet experts to curate our recommendations. This content is supported by our affiliate pet partners and we may receive a commission on the links provided.
Organic pet foods aren't super common, but some pet parents seek them out to ensure their fur-baby's food is good for them and the environment.
But what exactly are organic foods? The term "organic" gets thrown around a lot, but it's actually officially defined by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) regarding pet food.
Foods must meet standards set by the US Department of Agriculture's (USDA) National Organic Program (NOP), and guidelines to qualify as organic are high. Organic products must recycle resources, conserve local biodiversity, and maintain ecological balance.
Organic foods mustn't use artificial farming methods, including synthetic fertilizers, genetic modification, and irradiation. Plus, they should be free from antibiotics, artificial preservatives, and synthetic hormones.
Interested in feeding your fur-baby an organic diet? Scroll down for our guide to the best organic cat foods in 2024!
Overview
Primal Freeze-dried Nuggets
Best organic freeze-dried cat food
Primal Freeze-dried Nuggets are the best USDA-certified freeze-dried organic cat food available. Each recipe consists of humanely raised or wild-caught meat and the freshest produce. Primal uses high-pressure processing (HPP) to ensure their foods are pathogen-free while keeping them raw.
Alongside a quality cut of organic meat, each recipe contains produce like kale, squash, apples, pumpkin seeds, and broccoli to provide your fur-baby with all their essential vitamins and minerals. Every Primal Freeze-dried Nuggets recipe is grain-free.
Recipes include no legumes or lentils and contain no synthetic supplements. Primal Freeze-dried Nuggets aren't considered human-grade. Some recipes contain as much as 57% crude protein, which is above average for cat food.
Primal Freeze-dried Nuggets are complete and balanced, meeting the AAFCO nutrient profile guidelines for maintenance (adults).
Primal Freeze-dried Nuggets are available in the following six variations:
- Pork
- Venison
- Turkey
- Rabbit
- Beef & Salmon
- Chicken & Salmon
Primal Cat Food
Why Wag! Loves It
- 100% USDA-certified organic
- A quality cut of organic meat as the top ingredient
- No artificial nutritional supplements
- No grains, legumes, or lentils
Considerations & Concerns
- Water, broth, or raw goat milk needs to be added to each meal
- On the pricey side
What pet parents say about Primal Freeze-dried Nuggets
"My cats love these turkey nuggets. They show up when they hear me shake the bag!"
"I have three 11-year old siblings. And they all are enjoying this."
Read more reviews on Chewy.
Image sourced from the Chewy website. Copyright Primal Pet Foods.
Evanger's Organics Wet Cat Food
Best organic wet cat food
Evanger's is one of only a few companies producing USDA-certified organic wet cat food. It's very high quality, listing a premium cut of meat as the top ingredient in all its Organics recipes.
All Evanger's Organics recipes are grain-free with limited ingredients, making them a good choice for cats with food allergies. Evanger's thoughtfully chooses its ingredients. Butternut squash provides your cat with additional fiber, vitamin C, and potassium. It's also high in essential nutrients like taurine and Omega fatty acids.
Evanger's Organics cat food doesn't contain any meat meal or low-quality meat. That said, due to the manufacturing process, it can't be considered human-grade. It's made with 10% crude protein as a minimum, with 78% moisture which is average for cat food.
Evanger's Organics is complete and balanced, meeting the AAFCO nutrient profile guidelines for maintenance (adults).
Evangers Organics wet food is available in three flavors:
- Beef
- Braised Chicken
- Turkey and Butternut Squash
Evanger's Cat Food
Why Wag! Loves It
- 100% USDA-certified organic
- Organic cut of meat as the top ingredient
- Limited ingredients
- Kosher approved
Considerations & Concerns
- Some pet parents said their cat didn't like Evanger's Organics
- Only suitable for adult cats
Limited recipe variations
What pet parents say about Evanger's Organics wet cat food
"Cats love it. - Smells like fresh meat, nothing else. Since Newman's stopped selling cat food, this is pretty much some of the only worthwhile canned cat food around. Costs more than the Newman's did, but it seems to be at least as good quality-wise. It smells like fresh meat--quite delicious smelling, actually. Cat loves it and thrives on it."
"I have to mix this flavor with other flavors in order to get them to eat it. Will not order this flavor again!"
Read more reviews on Chewy.
Image sourced from Chewy. Copyright Evanger's Dog & Cat Food Co., Inc.
Stella & Chewy's Raw Freeze-Dried Dinner Morsels
Stella & Chewy's Raw Freeze-Dried Dinner Morsels might not be USDA-certified organic but contain 100% organic fruit and vegetables. While its meat isn't certified organic, its animals are well cared for. For example, its chickens, ducks, and turkeys are cage-free.
Stella & Chewy's Raw Freeze-Dried Dinner Morsels are made of over 98% animal protein — purrfect for your carnivorous cat. All recipes are grain-free, lentil-free, and potato-free. Stella & Chewy's fortifies each recipe with taurine and vitamin and mineral blend to meet your cat's nutritional needs.
Stella & Chewy's Raw Freeze-Dried Dinner Morsels comprise around 46% protein as dry matter on average, which is above average for raw cat food.
Stella & Chewy's Raw Freeze-Dried Dinner Morsels are complete and balanced, meeting the AAFCO nutrient profile guidelines for all life stages.
Stella & Chewy's Raw Freeze-Dried Dinner Morsels are available in the following eight variations:
- Rabbit
- Beef
- Chicken
- Duck
- Pork
- Salmon & Cod
- Turkey
- Salmon & Chicken
Stella & Chewy's Cat Food
Why Wag! Loves It
- Uses organic produce and responsibly sourced meat
- Consists of 98% animal protein
- Grain-free, lentil-free, and potato-free
- Suitable for all life stages
Considerations & Concerns
- Not USDA-certified organic
- On the pricey side
- Some pet parents complained about product consistency
What pet parents say about Stella & Chewy's Raw Freeze-Dried Dinner Morsels
"I have been looking for healthy options. I purchased this and my cats enjoy it. I feed it with their wet food and it disappears. I leave the big chunks as they all seem to like crunching it!!! Happy cat mom"
"When my cat started to negatively react to canned food, I remembered using a dehydrated food when she was first brought home from the shelter. This food is a winner! She vomits on the canned foods. No so with this. Just have to get used to rehydrating it."
Read more reviews on Chewy.
Image sourced from Chewy. Copyright Stella & Chewy's.
Tender & True Dry Cat Food
Tender & True is the original organic pet food company, becoming the first brand to be USDA-certified organic back in 2014. Today, its range of dry foods are among the best organic cat foods on the market.
All recipes list a quality cut of meat as the top ingredient, which suggests it's a high-quality cat food. However, recipes contain plant-based protein and carb sources, which could be considered filler.
For example, Tender & True Organic Check & Liver Recipe lists organic chicken, organic chicken meal, and organic tapioca starch as the top three ingredients. Aside from being high in fiber, tapioca starch isn’t very nutritious for cats.
Tender & True dry cat food isn't human-grade due to manufacturing processes and the use of meat meals in each recipe. All recipes contain over 30% protein, which is considered average for cat food.
Tender & True dry cat food recipes are complete and balanced, meeting the AAFCO nutrient profile guidelines for all life stages.
Tender & True dry cat food is available in these organic and non-organic variations:
- Organic Chicken & Liver
- Organic Turkey & Liver
- Organic Small Breed Turkey & Oats
- Chicken & Brown Rice
- Turkey & Brown Rice
- Salmon & Sweet Potato
- Ocean Whitefish & Potato
Tender & True Cat Food
Why Wag! Loves It
- 100% USDA-certified organic
- A quality cut of meat as the top ingredient
- Wide selection of recipes
- Suitable for all life stages
Considerations & Concerns
- Not human-grade
- Contains plant-based protein
- Includes potential filler ingredients like pea flour
What pet parents say about Tender & True dry cat food
"My cats are indoor/outdoor cats and eat hard food mostly. They are in super health, and that's why I always look for organic no grain food for them."
"My cats like it a lot a.nd I am glad to see a cat food company that cares about its sourcing."
Read more reviews on Chewy.
Image sourced from Chewy. Copyright Tender & True Pet.
FAQ
Is organic cat food expensive?
What's the difference between natural and organic cat food?
How does Wag! determine paw ratings for cat food?