“I switched from using regular kibble to these Pupford freeze-dried dog treats when doing our daily training routine. I love that they are small, do not have a strong smell and are not oily. My small pup goes crazy for them and considers them a high value reward. They are also low calorie and are made with healthy ingredients and real beef liver. I can’t wait to try other varieties.”

“This is my second time ordering these for my new puppy. These have come in handy while trying to leash train and housebreak our new boy! These give him an extra tasty reward that helped him learn FAST! We are a little over a week in with our training and he has made a SIGNIFICANT improvement! We’re almost 100% there and I don’t think we could have accomplished this feat as fast as we are without Pupford!”

“My pup adores these treats. I love that they're already small in size so I don't have to cut them up. These are mess-free and low-odor, so I just throw them in my belt bag for outings and have not had any issues. Quite expensive compared to other single ingredient, freeze dried beef treats, but since they're so high reward for my pup, I cave and get them.”

Read more reviews on Chewy.

Product image sourced from the Chewy website. Copyright Pupford LLC.

“I love that it has only 4 ingredients and my puppy loves them! I have been curious to try them myself.”

“My puppy LOVES these treats! We've been using these as his ‘special’ treats to help crate and potty train him. He gets so excited when he sees us open the bag and gobbles them up so fast. My husband actually tried them as well and thought they were pretty good...(lol) I'm happy they're made with good, simple, and clean ingredients that are all healthy and tasty for my pup! The only downside is that they're too big for our puppy normally so we cut them into smaller pieces and that means crumbs everywhere!”

“My dogs are not food motivated, so [it makes it] harder to [train]. But this treat is the only one they like and focus on training sessions.”

Read more reviews on Maxbone.

Product image sourced from the Maxbone website. Copyright maxbone.

“We use these as a high reward training treat for our GSP puppy. They are a great size for training and he loves the smell of them. Particularly good for getting him moving when distracted by playing ‘find it.’”

“I have two treat obsessed dogs, and they both love these treats. I love the tiny star shape. They're small enough to fit in treat dispensing toys, or to use for training. Would definitely buy again.”

“I worked with a dog trainer to help my dog with her leash reactivity. Part of our training entails using treats throughout her daily walks- this can mean lots of treats so it’s important for us to use a training treat so as to not give her excess calories. Previously we were using freeze dried training treats from another brand, but she seems to get even more excited for these. I think [it’s] because it has a softer texture and these have a stronger meat smell. My dog is blind so this last one is just for me: I like the cute little star shape!”

Read more reviews on Jinx.

Product image sourced from the Jinx website. Copyright Jinx, Inc.

“I do physical therapy/conditioning exercises with my dog, and I've found these treats to be the best low value, low calorie rewards for our purposes or for extended training sessions. My dog likes them enough to work for them, but doesn't love them so much that they don't make him over-aroused like some smelly or meat based treats do. They are tiny and low calorie with simple ingredients, so they are perfect for long sessions where you are asking your dog for lots of behaviors.”

“Our dog with allergies is doing much better (i.e. less itchy) on these than her previous treats, thank goodness! They are TINY. I wish each one was twice the size, even for our 15lb dog. But still worth it. We did transfer to a sealable container as the bag they come in isn't meant for storing.”

“We are stuck on these in both flavors for my 6 pound Pom. We housebroke her with treats and so she does receive a treat whenever she goes pee or poo outside. It works well because Poms are difficult to housebreak. I love these and so does my Pom, Livvie. Since they are so tiny, there is no danger of her getting fat from [treats] and also because they are organic and do not contain any [undesirable] ingredients.”

Read more reviews on Chewy.

Product image sourced from the Chewy website. Copyright Wet Noses Inc.

“I have 2 Maltese pups and they absolutely loved these. They go crazy for them as soon as [they] hear the baggie jingle. I also have a senior Pomeranian [whose] teeth are [starting] to go. These treats are soft enough for him to enjoy, and not have to worry about him hurting himself.”

“Our 5 month old puppy loves these treats. We were having a hard time potty training him but since using these as a reward, we were rewarded in just 2 weeks!!!”

“My 9mo puppy loves these. Easy to break into smaller sizes since it’s soft and she loves them more than the other treats we have now. Only issue is they get hard if you leave the bag open but that’s more of a me problem ha.”

Read more reviews on Chewy.

Product image sourced from the Chewy website. Copyright Wellness Pet, LLC.