Dogs are sometimes very vocal when playing with other dogs, and it has nothing to do with aggression. It may sound bad, but it's usually not. Your dog might growl at you when he's being petted, because he's really liking it, or because he's trying to get your attention. These types of growling are "good growling" and are nothing to be worried about. Dogs may also growl, however, when they are asking for space, whether that may be because they are being territorial or because they are scared or uncomfortable--it's important to listen.
For this command, in particular, you want to be sure that we reward the "good growling" and not the aggressive or fearful growling. You don't want to reward your dog for being in an aggressive or fearful state. So, when you are trying to induce the growl, make sure it's coming from a playful place and not a place of fear.
You will need a large space to teach this command, preferably distraction-free. The key aspect of training this command is speed on your part when rewarding. You want to reward at exactly the moment your dog is growling. Growling is usually preceded or followed by a bark, and you don't want to reward a bark, you want to reward the growl. A clicker is a great tool for capturing this kind of behavior because you can catch it exactly the right moment.
You can teach this command to adults and puppies alike and it can take you as little as a day.
My dog and I are in the process of getting our qualifications for working security. He is specialized in tracking but working on intimidation techniques was recommended as well. The problem is, he is an extremely well tempered dog who wouldn't hurt a fly. I have him for almost half a year now and in that time he only growled once during a bad dream. Is there any other way to teach him?
Hello Simon, Typically growling is taught by either initiating the growl or capturing when pup does it on their own. Since your dog rarely growls on his own the trick will be finding something that he will growl at. The easiest way to get a good-natured dog to growl is usually during play - because most growling that takes place during play isn't a sign of aggression but for fun. Rougher play like tug of war and sometimes wrestling elicits many dogs to growl. If your pup doesn't play tug of war you will have to start by getting them interested in it by running away from pup with the toy, moving it along the ground like an animal (toys shaped like animals without stuffing in them are good for this), making it squeak, tossing it small distances, and teasing them a bit with the toy by making it run near them then away again. Praise pup excitedly whenever he shows any interest in the toy, mouths it, tugs on it, and especially vocalizes at all. Keep your energy really excited and fun. If tug doesn't work you will have to get really creative. Try different sound recordings, have people make some weird noises outside or in usual places like under the house, take pup places around other animals (safely) and see if you can elicit any growling that way. If you truly cannot get pup to growl, then you might want to focus on other intimidating things like a lift lip or bark. A lift lip is often taught using peanut butter and a clicker so doesn't have to require aggressive tendencies. A bark can be due to excitement, then shaped into a deeper bark using rewards as training progresses. Staring at a person intently is another good option, but you would need to shape what would probably start as a happy, open mouthed focus on you, to a close mouthed, more intent stare that appears intimidating - look up a Border Collie stare to get an idea of what to shape. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden
Was this experience helpful?
I’m trying to teach him growl. He knows speak and will bark instead of growling. He only growls when we play tug. I need him to growl without the tug rope in his mouth and us playing tug.
Hello Blair, I suggest practicing capturing the growl. Start a game of tug and say "Growl!" (or whatever cue word you want to use) right when he growls. Quickly praise him for growling and let go of the rope, then pull a treat out of your pocket or a treat pouch hidden behind you and hold a treat in front of his nose until he lets go of the rope and eats it. Show him that your hands are empty so he won't keep looking for treats, and continue the tug game. Practice this over and over during tug often - letting him growl and tug for longer sometimes so that he stays engaged in the game overall. Eventually, once he seems to be learning the command while playing, say growl while he is tugging but before he growls, then praise and reward when he growls - even if it takes him a few seconds and you getting him excited with the toy for him to growl then. Beginning to say the command before he growls but while he is still in that excited mode and likely to growl will help him start to make the transition to growling on cue. When he will always growl on command while playing, then periodically command him to growl when he is excited but not tugging yet - from there you will slowly phase out the tug toy, and the growl command become a command he can do on cue at anytime. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden
Was this experience helpful?