wag-logo
How to Train Your Dog to Stop Being Fearful
Hard difficulty iconHard
Time icon1-12 Months
Behavior training category iconBehavior
Introduction

Your rescue dog has a bizarre habit. Whenever he sees an umbrella, he starts to cower. The closer you draw to a person holding an umbrella, the more the dog's body language changes. He holds his head low to the ground, his tail clamps between his back legs, and he starts to shake. 

Once, when you walked past a woman with an umbrella, and she reached down to stroke the dog, you saw his lip curl in a snarl. This alarmed you greatly, and so now whenever you see someone carrying an umbrella you tighten the leash, haul the dog towards you, and drag him away. 

Indeed, things seem to be getting worse rather than better, and taking him for walks in the rain is impossible. A friend suggested putting an umbrella in the dog's bed so that he learns there's nothing to worry about, but this doesn't feel right to you. But this still leaves the question of how to handle his growing fear. 

Top
Defining Tasks

Teaching a dog to stop being fearful can only be done by building his self-confidence. This means changing how his mind responds in certain situations and turning negative associations into positive ones. To do this requires great patience and a series of controlled exposures to the feared event or object, but at sufficient distance that the dog doesn't feel anxious. You then reward his brave behavior, and gradually step a little closer, but stopping before the dog's fear is aroused. 

In addition, it's important to avoid actions that will make matters worse. This means never forcing the dog to face up to his fears, but counterintuitively it also means never soothing or petting the dog in a fearful situation. 

Top
Getting Started

Socialization is a vital part of a puppy growing up into a well-adjusted and confident adult dog. Young puppies under the age of 18 weeks of age are most open to accepting novel situations, but once this time has passed they become more closed minded. Know that adult dogs can be tough to retrain, but with knowledge, patience, and understanding you can bring things under control. 

You will need: 

  •  Training treats
  • A treat pouch to wear on your belt
  • A collar and leash
  • A soft muzzle for potential fear biters
  • A stooge item or person with which to make the dog familiar
  • Plenty of time, patience, and understanding

Top

The Desensitize the Dog Method

Most Recommended

1 Vote

Ribbon icon

Most Recommended

1 Vote

Ribbon icon
1

Understand the idea

A fearful dog jumps to conclusions when they see something (say an umbrella) that they are frightened of. He immediately assumes the umbrella is dangerous and becomes fearful. Desensitization is a slow process whereby the dog is taught to make new assumptions about the umbrella and link it to good things happening rather than bad.

2

Find the dog's 'safe distance' from the object

Let's work with the idea the dog is frightened of umbrellas. However, there is a distance at which the umbrella is sufficiently far away that the dog sees it but without reacting fearfully. The first step is to work out where this is. If it's across a room, say 15 feet away, then have the dog sit, praise him, and give him a treat for seeing the umbrella but being so brave.

3

Take a step closer

With the dog's attention on you (perhaps with the aid of a treat), take a step closer to the umbrella. Just one step, nothing too adventurous. If the dog is still ignoring the umbrella and remaining calm, fuss and reward him. This is his new 'safe' distance from the feared object.

4

Move closer still

Judge how your dog is coping. If he's just fine, then take another step closer. Keep rewarding him for being brave. Be vigilant for the dog's body language and as soon as he starts to show signs of distress or discomfort (such as cowering, lip licking, yawning, tail tucking, or lowering the head), then distract the dog and walk away from the umbrella. Start your next session at the previous safe distance and slowly step closer.

5

Scatter treats around the feared object

It's also helpful to make the object more inviting, by scattering tasty treats around it. Once the dog plucks up the courage to step close enough to see and smell the treats, the object takes on a new interest over and above it being scary. Take things slowly and in gradual steps. Most fearful behavior is deeply ingrained and so it will take a considerable amount of time to unlearn these old associations.

The Distract the Dog Method

Effective

1 Vote

Ribbon icon

Effective

1 Vote

Ribbon icon
1

Understand the idea

By giving the dog something else to think about, this helps distract him from the situation he is fearful about. A good example is the dog who is fearful in the waiting room at the vet clinic. This is the ideal situation in which to distract the dog with some basic obedience exercises such as 'sit', 'down', and 'stay'. This has the dog focusing on you, rather than anything that's about to happen with the vet, plus it sends out a powerful message that you are in control - which in a scary situation is comforting for the dog.

2

Carry a distraction with you

If you know your dog is fearful of large hairy dogs, then it's helpful to plan what you'll do when you meet one on a walk. Instead of pulling your dog away (which reinforces the idea there's something to be concerned about), keep a squeaky toy in your pocket and use it as a distraction. Pull the toy out and squeak it vigorously. Once you have the dog's attention, praise him, and in a bright happy voice have him walk to heel as you walk in a different direction to the perceived threat. This avoids reinforcing the fear and dodges the sticky situation.

3

Teach the 'look' command

Train the dog to look at you and you can stop him looking at the object he's fearful over and keep his attention while it passes. Teaching 'look' is simple. Hold a tasty treat near the dog's nose to get his attention. Stand tall and travel the treat from the dog's nose to a place between your eyes. As the dog's gaze follows the treat say "look" in a firm but happy voice. Practice this at home, and then out on walks. The idea is to have the dog look at your eyes on cue, in order to receive a treat. With enough training, the dog will 'look' on command, regardless of whether you are holding a treat or not.

4

Work on basic obedience

Spend 5 - 10 minutes, twice a day working on basic commands such as 'sit', stay', and 'down'. This gets the dog in the habit of paying attention to you, and can be used in situations where the dog might otherwise focus on something he fears. This gives you long enough to distract the dog and walk away from the situation. By building up the number of times the dog encounters a fearful situation but it is dealt with calmly, he will gradually become more confident.

5

Work on more advanced commands

Teaching a rock solid recall is a great way for keeping control. Fearful dogs are prone to bolting and running out of control, whereas when you work on a solid recall, you can bring the dog back to your side and out of danger.

The What NOT to Do Method

Least Recommended

1 Vote

Ribbon icon

Least Recommended

1 Vote

Ribbon icon
1

Never force a dog to face his fears

An out-dated technique called 'flooding' should be avoided at all costs. This is when a dog is forced to directly face the feared object or situation, in order to prove to him that it's safe. Superficially this may appear to work, but only because the dog is frozen with fear. In reality, the dog is mentally traumatized and his fear is heightened rather than alleviated.

2

Never shout at or punish a fearful dog

A dog that behaves badly in a situation he's frightened of is likely trying to escape and in a distressed frame of mind. If you shout, smack, or punish him, this only adds to his anxiety and makes the situation worse. Instead, try to distract him, or keep him restrained on a leash while you withdraw from the situation.

3

Do NOT reassure a fearful dog

It is a natural human reaction to empathize with the dog's fear and soothe him with soft words and stroke him. Unfortunately, this rewards the dog for feeling fearful, and in effect trains him to be anxious. Indeed, in the dog's mind your 'praise' verifies that he is right to be afraid, which again makes things worse. Instead, it is best to act normally, so the dog picks up from your body language that there's nothing to be fearful of.

4

Do NOT tense up in anticipation

When you know your dog is fearful of large hairy hounds and you see one approaching across the park, a natural reaction is to tighten the leash and pull your dog towards you. However, this is counterproductive as your anxiety transmits itself down the lead and the dog believes once again he is right to be afraid. Instead, step out briskly in a wide arc around the hairy dog, avoiding a head-on confrontation.

5

Do NOT risk a fearful dog biting

Many aggressive dogs are actually fearful, and they attack as their only means of avoiding a fearful situation. While retraining your dog, don't take any risks. If necessary, for your safety and that of the general public, muzzle the dog when in public places.

Written by Pippa Elliott

Veterinary reviewed by:

Published: 11/13/2017, edited: 01/08/2021

Training Questions and Answers

Lelo
Staffordshire Bull Terrier
8 Years
Question
0 found this helpful
0 found this helpful

Lelo is an amazing dog. So timid loving in fact she is always walked off lead everywhere as her recall is fantastic even next to a busy road. We have recently tried to bring in a new pup and all she shows is fear. Following advice i had them separated where they can see each other and she will be fine then all of a sudden bark very aggressively at him. She wont come near him if you have him in your arms or on your knee. I have had her maybe 20cm away from the pups face with treats but as soon as she gets it she runs away again. Im fearful she is going to harm the pup if the pup tries to go near her. I have a cage for the pup which we are trying for the first time tonight so lelo they can hopefully be in the same room. My questions mainly are. At what point is it ok to allow the pup out and her down beside him? How can i allow the pup to be able to play, pee- hes still indoors yet without her freaking out? Is the cage a good idea? As obviously we cant have the walk yet. And she generally is fine with dogs out walking until they sniff her behind! Im desperate for her to accept him but incredibly fearful she will harm him

June 11, 2019

Lelo's Owner

Caitlin Crittenden - Dog Trainer

1128 Dog owners recommended

Hello Lauren, I suggest hiring professional help to come to your home and work with her and you. The crate is a great idea. At his age he will need to take a lot of naps also, so the crate is a safe place for that and it can be great for potty training, preventing separation anxiety, preventing destructive chewing, and a number of other things - you can give him Kongs stuffed with dog food a bit of liver paste to help him adjust to the crate and stay occupied in it. You may also want to purchase an exercise pen. I would only leave him in the exercise pen when you are in the room though, since it is less durable than the crate and could be knocked over by your older dog possibly if she were persistent - look for a more sturdy one or anchor it to walls in a corner too. In the exercise pen pup can play with toys and have more room to run around. Right now they will need to be in separate rooms while loose. When its time to train pup, I suggest putting Lelo in another room or crating her in another room if she is crate trained. They should not be loose together until your older dog can remain calm at all times when you are working with the dogs together or pup is in the exercise pen playing in the same room. I would not leave them unsupervised for a very long time. Whenever pup enters the room, before Lelo reacts poorly, reward her with a treat. Whenever she acts calm or tolerant around pup reward her. She does not have to get close too soon right now. You simply want to associate the pup's appearance and actions with good things for Lelo - to help her feel better about him. Do not reward when she is displaying aggression and anxiety. Do not pet then either. instead act firm, confident, and calm. You want to encourage calmness, tolerance, and friendliness (carefully) by rewarding it with praise, pets, and treats. You don't want to reward aggression and fear with praise, pets, or food - so pay attention to what her body language is like when you reward. I highly suggest hiring a trainer to help you. You may need to get Lelo used to wearing a soft silicone basket muzzle for pups safety, but this will not fix the root issue, only temporarily provide extra safety. The fear- aggression needs to be addressed still. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

June 12, 2019

Brie
Maltese Shih Tzu
11 Years
Question
0 found this helpful
0 found this helpful

Where to start? Brie was attacked by an unleashed dog when she was 6 months old. She's been scared of them ever since even though we've tried resocializing her over the years. She's always been great with people, very loving and cuddly. Three weeks ago we took her to her regular groomer. Not her favorite place and it usually takes her a day or two to recuperate but this time was different. She stayed upstairs refusing to come down over that weekend. I could coax her to go outside and she's been eating, drinking water, going to the bathroom, but her behavior did a 180. Concerned we took her to our vet first thing Monday morning. We explained that we thought something had happened at the groomers. We had checked every square inch of her and there was nothing physical so we assumed something must have scared her. After a thorough examination, our vet agreed. She was given a clean bill of health and we brought her home hoping she would come out of it. As the last three weeks have gone by, sometimes it's as if she's forgotten but most of the time she's very anxious. She has switched from always being by my side to being stuck like glue to my husband. The first few days afterward any time I tried to pet her she would tremble in fear. If my husband is not home she will sometimes hop up on the couch with me but most often I have to go looking for her. She will not come when called, has tried to bolt out of the garage door, has completely ignored her beloved stuffed frog and pants and paces. We are at a complete loss as to what to do. And we're heartbroken thinking we may have permanently lost our little love bug.

March 26, 2019

Brie's Owner

Caitlin Crittenden - Dog Trainer

1128 Dog owners recommended

Hello Sharon, I suggest starting some type of confidence building training with her. Something like modified agility - to suite her age, trick training through positive reinforcement, or another fun canine sport that could be modified for her age. I suggest hiring a private trainer for this so that you do not have to be in a class with other dogs. In general look for an activity that would be fun, build her confidence and encourage your relationship with her in a way that is upbeat, confident, and has leadership, and not feeling sorry for her or feeling worried for her - dogs pick up on that and it can make them feel even more insecure when you are not confident. A fun activity that's up beat helps both of you focus on learning, having fun, and not feeling worried. I am sure it goes without saying, but obviously do not return to that groomer. It does sound like something traumatizing happened, even if it was an accident or simply the environment that day. While working on the training with her, also simply give her time. Help her move through it by being upbeat, can and confident yourself but also know that she may just need time to feel safe again. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

March 27, 2019