How to Train Your Dog to Stop Barking for Attention

Medium
1-3 Weeks
Behavior

Introduction

You’ve sat down with the friend you haven’t seen in months, coffee in hand and gossip being exchanged. Your needs canine pal isn’t so pleased that Susan’s getting all the attention, though. He keeps barking, putting a damper on this relaxing catch-up. You’ve tried sending him out of the room but then he just barks from outside. You spend most of the day with him, don’t you deserve a little break every once in a while?

It’s exactly the same when you settle down for this week's episode of your favorite show. You can’t even hear the dialogue over the sound of constant barking. If you could get a handle on this attention seeking behavior, you could enjoy a few moments to yourself without having clinger level 100 barking in your ear.

Defining Tasks

Training your dog not to bark for attention is, thankfully, not too complicated. The biggest hurdle is showing him that attention-seeking barking won’t give him what he wants. You need to break that cycle of behavior, which will take resilience. You’ll also need to use obedience commands so you can instruct him to stop barking with ease. If he’s a puppy and this attention seeking behavior is relatively new, then training it out of him may take just a week or so. If this behavior has been years in the making, then you may need up to three weeks before you finally get peace and quiet.

Succeed with this new regime and you’ll never have to worry about having friends and family over again. You’ll be able to enjoy just their company for a change. You may also find you can instruct your dog to stop barking in a range of other situations too.

Getting Started

Before work begins, you’ll need a few bits. His favorite food or treats will play an essential role in training, so stock up! You’ll also need time each day to commit to training during times that trigger his attention-seeking barking.

A quiet room, free from distractions, will also be needed for obedience training. For one of the methods, invest in a citronella or water spraying remote-controlled collar. They can be bought from a variety of stores.

 Apart from that, just bring patience and a positive mental attitude and you’re good to get to work!

The Routine Method

Most Recommended
1 Vote
Step
1
Up the exercise
A tired dog won’t want half the attention a dog full of energy will. That means take him on an extra or longer walk. Alternatively, play fetch with him when you’re walking. The short sprints will tire him out. If he’s napping all evening he won’t be pestering you for attention.
Step
2
Tug of war
Get his favorite toy and play tug of war with him for 10 minutes each day. Not only will this help knacker him out, it will give him some solid bonding time and attention from his owner.
Step
3
Set play times
Establish a routine where you play with him at the same time each day. You may want to split it up into once in the morning and once in the evening. If he knows he’s got play time coming up after dinner he won’t be so desperate for attention the rest of the time.
Step
4
Be firm
If he does start barking for attention, remove him from your environment. Take him out the room, or leave the room yourself. Don’t talk to him, don’t shout at him, just distance yourself from him. If he doesn’t ever get the attention he wants, he’ll learn there’s no point barking in the first place.
Step
5
Consider a deterrent
If these steps don’t yield swift results, you can use a remote controlled collar as well. You can get collars that release an unpleasant burst of citronella or water. Just hit the button when he starts barking and this will be an added deterrent to keep him silent. Use all of these steps in conjunction with each other for the best results.
Recommend training method?

The Cold Shoulder Method

Effective
0 Votes
Step
1
Turn around
When he starts barking, turn away from him and completely ignore him. He’s barking because he wants your attention, so even looking at him may give him the satisfaction he wants. So make sure you give him nothing.
Step
2
Wait for him to stop
As soon as he stops, you can turn around and give him attention, but you MUST wait for him to stop. If you give in after 15 minutes, he’ll know next time that he has to bark for that long to get your attention, so be resilient.
Step
3
Reward
When he has fallen silent, turn around and give him a treat and some attention. Slowly, he will learn the quickest way to get attention is to be quiet.
Step
4
Increase the time before reward
After a couple of days, start to increase the time he has to be quiet for before you turn around and give him attention. After a week, you’ll find he’ll sit there silently for up to 10 seconds before you turn around and give him a treat.
Step
5
Be consistent
If you give in just once or twice half way through training, you’ll be seriously delaying results. You must stamp out giving him any and all attention. This is a case of being cruel to be kind, so stay strong!
Recommend training method?

The Quiet Method

Effective
0 Votes
Step
1
Induce the barking
Put him in a situation when he’s likely to bark for attention, so watch TV or ignore him. Once he starts barking, take no notice of him and carry on with what you were doing.
Step
2
‘Quiet’
Wait for him to stop barking, then when he does, issue the 'quiet' command and give him a treat. Say the command in a serious tone of voice, you want him to know you mean business. You can use any word or phrase you want, so feel free to get creative. You may have to wait 10 minutes for him to fall silent, so be patient.
Step
3
Treat
Once you give the command, give him a treat too. You can then give him some attention and some verbal praise. Over time, he will start to associate the ‘stop’ or 'quiet' command with falling silent and tasty rewards. Practice this each time he barks for the first few days.
Step
4
Give the command earlier
Now instead of waiting for him to finish barking, start using the command while he is barking. Issue it only once, you need to show him you expect results straight away. By this point he’ll know the command is a cue to be quiet and that food awaits him if he does. Then reward him with a treat and praise as before.
Step
5
Consistency
Now start issuing the command whenever he barks for attention. Be quick to issue it and he’ll fall silent straight away. Keep doing this for as long as it takes to cut out the barking altogether. You can also use this command to get him to stop barking in other situations, from barking at other dogs to people approaching the door.
Recommend training method?

Success Stories and Training Questions

Training Questions and Answers

Question
Bruin
Labrador Retriever
3 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Bruin
Labrador Retriever
3 Months

Barking at me for attention. If I ignore him he nips at my legs. I have tried ignoring him and then rewarding him when he is quite. How long do wait in between the barking and the quiet?

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Heidi, I suggest teaching an Out command for this behavior and making him leave the room when he is being pushy. When you do this, if he disobeys your Out command, follow the section on how to use out for pushy behavior from the article linked below. When you first do this he will probably try harder to get your attention. Imagine yourself as a brick wall or drill sergeant - be firm, unwavering, but very, very calm. Repeat walking toward him firmly but calmly until he backs out of the area and stands two feet away from you. It's okay if you have to move him with your legs if he doesn't get out of the way, just don't step on his paws. If he doesn't give you two feet or darts back in, repeat walking toward him firmly. At first he will probably get more excited but after a few repetitions he should start to decide that this isn't fun anymore and calm down, then calm down quicker in the future, until he only needs to be told Out to leave. Also, when he gets super ramped up he may actually need some quiet time. Many young puppies get more and more wound up when they are timid or overstimulated - and benefit from being put in a crate with a food stuffed chew toy to calm back down and take a nap if needed. Out command: https://www.petful.com/behaviors/how-to-teach-a-dog-the-out-command/ Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Bruin's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Dory
Lhasapoo
8 Months
2 found helpful
Question
2 found helpful
Dory
Lhasapoo
8 Months

Dory is a quiet dog most of the time. I am an artist working from home and at least once a day she will just start barking at me for attention. I have tired walking away but she will follow me and gently nip my leg. I have tired calm voice commands e.g “quiet” but nothing appears to stop her until I pick her up or distract her with a toy, but I am worried I am teaching her to bark for my attention please help.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Gemma, To get Dory to stop barking at you for attention first create a confined, safe area in another room, where she cannot see you. You can use an exercise pen for this, or a bathroom with the trash can and bath mats taken up and a baby gate across the doorway, or another small and safe area that she cannot escape from. Whenever she begins to bark at your for attention, calmly take her into that confined area, without speaking to her, and leave her in there until she has been quiet for at least five minutes. Also prevent the barking episodes by taking breaks when you are able, to before she gets too restless, and play with her, train her, or exercise her during those breaks. While you are busy working give her something to entertain herself with, such as a Kong toy stuffed with her dog food and a bit of peanut butter, or a dog puzzle toy filled with dry dog food, or a wobble toy that she has to push around to get food out of, Kong brand makes one. You can feed her entire food for the day in these types of toys if you would like to. Simply measure out her food for the day and fill all of the different toys with her dog food. This will give her a job to do too while you work. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Dory's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Dory
Lhasapoo
8 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Dory
Lhasapoo
8 Months

Hello, I found this website so helpful for our family being a new dog owner.

Our Dory is doing so well, we are very happy with her progress. There are still small things we would like to sort out and would appreciate any professional advise.

We recently changed her lead and harness from a retractable lead to a standard length (it has a bit of bounce) she walks well.

But when we walk as a family (five of us) if a child walks away or someone is slow she starts to whine (she sounds very frantic) and pulls back or front. We try to ignore it and continue.

But how can I help curb this behaviour.

Please help!

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Gemma, I am so glad that you have found the website helpful. Congratulations on your dog and the progress that you have made! When Dory is walking with the entire family, the family itself is a form of distraction, even more so than most distractions that you pass, and just like any other training, you have to practice and work up to a dog being able to do a command in the presence of distractions. It might not be ideal, but the answer is to practice your heel work during the walk, while other family members are present. To help this go faster you can try to go on extra walks that everyone expects to just be training walks. Whenever she begins to move her head past your leg at all, turn directly in front of her at a ninety degree angle, so that she has to slow down and adjust her walking to stay with you and not run into your leg. Whenever she lags behind you, go faster and hurry her up. Act excited to get her to focus back on you, and to keep her moving. Change directions frequently when she gets too distracted by one of the kids, so that she has to pay attention to you again in order to keep up. Also bring treats in a Zip-Lock bag in your pocket, and when she is looking at you and walking right beside you, instead of focusing on other things like your kids, praise her and reach down to give her a treat while you are walking. The more you practice teaching her to walk in the heel position beside you while walking with your family, the better she should get, so that walks will eventually be easy with her. The inconvenience of practicing on walks now with her can make walks for the rest of her life with everyone easier. Another option is to purchase a training device such as an gentle leader, or front clip harness, designed to help with the pulling. The harness or gentle leader itself will not train her, she will still need you to work on the training while walking with your family without the harness or gentle leader at other times, but during walks when you cannot train her, you can use the device to prevent her from pulling and developing worse habits. Doing that will give you options for each walk. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Dory's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Thor and Loki
Labrador Terrier
5 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Thor and Loki
Labrador Terrier
5 Months

I am training two dogs at the same time. They do well separately but the minute they are together they do not listen to anything unless I say treat. I learned after the fact that I should not have resued litter mates but the damage is done.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Norma, Unfortunately another dog is a huge distraction, so it is not unusual for the puppies to only listen when separate. To help them learn, work on training both puppies separately every day, even fifteen minute training sessions every day for each puppy will help. Practice the commands that each puppy knows around distractions such as people, other dogs, smells, sights, and other animals, in addition to teaching new commands during the sessions. If you can recruit another person to help you, then have training sessions with both puppies together as often as you can as well. Have one person focus on one puppy at a time. Doing this should help the puppies to learn to listen when the distraction of the other puppy is there. You can also work on training the two puppies together on you own, but everything that you work on during those training sessions needs to be easier versions of everything that the puppies already know, since it will be harder for the puppies to focus around each other. Practice new commands and harder versions of the commands that they already know during individual training sessions, with just one puppy at a time, and practice commands that the puppies have already learned separately during training sessions with both puppies there also. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Thor and Loki's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Ember
Miniature Goldendoodle
4 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Ember
Miniature Goldendoodle
4 Months

I realize she is young, however we want to deal with any bad habits early on. Ember has started to bark for attention, or to get in the house, and when I took her to work with me, she would bark to get my attention or the receptionists attention when we took our eyes off her. I've read where you used the "quiet" option, but the trick is, she only barks once, and then she's quiet. She doesn't bark incessantly, where I could ignore her. We are a chiropractic and massage clinic, so no barking is welcome. We are giving her attention when she barks though by telling her "no barking" and it seems that's enough for her until we turn our attention away again. Then she will let out another bark. I hope this is making sense. Our previous dog barked so much, all the time, that we are very sensitive to not wanting her to even think about barking. Thank you. I hope we can do a good job training our precious puppy.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Serene, The first step will be to teach her the "Quiet" command if you can get her to bark on demand at other times. Good ways to trigger her barking are by ringing the door or playing recordings of other dogs or sirens. Once she understands the meaning of that command, then practice telling her "Quiet" and then ignoring her to trigger the attention seeking barking again. When she barks again, even if it has been several minutes, then discipline her. A remote controlled vibration collar or something gentle but a bit startling or unpleasant is the type of thing you should look for. You can also discipline with something called a pet convincer, which is simply a small can of pressurized air that you blow on her side, not face, when you tell her "Ah Ah" when she barks. The remote vibration collar is not associated with you though. She is more likely to think that it is related to her barking and that removes the negative attention from the correction also. The reason for teaching her "Quiet" first is so that you can tell her that command the first time that she barks so that when you correct her five or ten minutes later for barking again for attention, the correction is for disobedience, and it is easier for her to understand what she did wrong and what she is supposed to be doing. If she does not bark again a few minutes later when you go back to ignoring her, then you can skip the initial "Quiet" command and instead simply correct her the first time that she barks. You want your correction to surprise her a bit and be slightly unpleasant but not be overly harsh or scary at her age. Also, work on calm duration commands like a long Down-Stay or "Place" command in general to teach him to settle down better. Here is a link to an article on how to teach the "Quiet" command. Follow the "Quiet" method from that article: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Ember's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Dory
Lhasapoo
12 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Dory
Lhasapoo
12 Months

Hello I found this website very helpful before so I wanted to ask again! Dory responded very well 4 months ago and after being crated when she barked. After so many days it eased. We had her spayed 3 weeks ago and 14 days after her recovery the barking for attention has started again and she growls (wagging tail and no teeth showing) when I go to place her in her crate she runs away. She is selective when she wants to sit on command too but I know she knows what I am asking of her! Is this dog adolescents? Will she grow out of this behaviour? Do I just continue the training I was doing before? Am I doing anything wrong? She is a wonderful dog otherwise lol. Thank you

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Gemma, So glad you found the website helpful last time. First, make sure that she is not experiencing discomfort from being moved when you try to put her in her crate. If she growls when you touch her or push on her in a particular area, then she needs to be check out by your vet to make sure that she healed from her surgery alright. If she is alright physically and does not seem sore, then her recent behavior might be due to how she was handled while at the vet or after she got home. If she associates the crate with her bad experience for some reason, then she would likely act afraid and protest the crate. Be consistent and insist calmly but firmly that she obeys your commands, but focus proactively on getting her over her potential fear of the crate again. Go back to the basics of crate training and make the crate a really rewarding location. Check out the article that I have linked below and follow all of the methods. Especially placing a food stuffed Kong and treats in the crate with her when you put her inside so that she will look forward to being in there more. https://wagwalking.com/training/like-a-crate If she seems to protest all touch but is not in pain anymore, then she might be afraid of being handled because it caused her pain after her surgery. Work on handling exercises with her. At every meal you can feed her her dinner one piece at a time. Gently touch an area of her body while you give her a treat. Touch an ear and give a treat. Touch her paw and giver her a treat. Touch her tail and give her a treat. Touch her belly and give her a treat. Lift her up a bit and give her three treats. Repeat this will her whole body as often as you can for a couple of months, until she loves being touched everywhere again. Be extra gentle and spend extra time touching areas that she seems to dislike. When you command her to sit and she disobeys, then place the fingers of one of your hands on either side of the base of her tail, where her tail connects to her bottom and back. Cup your other hand underneath her chin, and gently but firmly press your fingers into the muscle on either side of the base of her tail while you carefully lift her chin up. This should cause her to sit in order to get away from your fingers and hand. If she sits on her own, then reward her with life rewards such as a walk, a pet, her dinner, a ball toss, or something else that she likes. If she will not sit, then follow through on your command by gently coercing her into the position with your hands. If you feel like she is struggling with respect for you in general, then check out this article below. https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-doberman-to-listen-to-you If all of this behavior is very unusual and new for her after being spayed, then visit your vet and make sure that she is not in pain or having hormonal issues. Those things could cause her to feel bad and act grumpy. If it is not unusual, then it is likely age related or experience related and it is time to work on enforcing her commands, practicing around distractions, and rebuilding trust of touch and the crate. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Dory's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Dory
Lhasa Apso
12 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Dory
Lhasa Apso
12 Months

Hello Thank you for your reply! No sorry I think I wasn’t clear! She is not in any pain, and likes her crate. But when she barks for attention she does not want to go in the crate willingly as excited! So I put her in there is that the wrong way? She had these behaviours before being spayed but she had overcome them. Now at 12 months they have returned. Do I just calmly be firm.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Gemma, Yes, have her go into the crate even if she does not want to. When you put her in there put a Kong stuffed with food in there with her to help her learn to like her crate again, but put her in even if she does not walk in willingly. Since she is resisting you in some other areas too, she is likely just testing out the waters to see if you really mean what you say, so when you tell her to do something have her do it. If she is hard to catch or acting aggressive, then keep a drag leash on her, without a handle so that it will not snag on things, while you are home to supervise for right now. When it's time to go into the crate calmly go over to her and step on the end of the leash and pick it up, then quickly lead her over to the crate so that she does not have time to protest or stop. Use her forward momentum to move her into the crate with the leash without pausing. Tell her "Crate", "Room", or some other word that means go into your crate while she is going inside. When she turns around, take off her leash, give her the food stuffed Kong, and close the door. Ignore her protests. When you let her out of the crate, open the door a bit and if she tries to rush out close it again. Repeat this until you can open the door all the way and she will stay inside. When she is waiting for permission to leave and looking to you for direction, then tell her "Okay" and let her out. By doing that you are adding more boundaries so that she will learn that when it's time to go in the crate and stay in the crate she needs to listen, even without being forced and even when the door is open! Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Dory's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Rose
Labrador Retriever
3 Years
1 found helpful
Question
1 found helpful
Rose
Labrador Retriever
3 Years

My dog is not letting me sleep at night. She barks for attention. I can't reward train her because she doesn't bark when I'm in the room so there is nothing to "correct". Shes 3 years old and spayed, her mom is a yellow lab, dad is a complete mutt. He looks chow and produces rottie patterned babies. She plays and runs and wrestles in the yard with my other dog before bed. Shes watered, fed, and sent to potty. She doesnt play with toys/chews because she eats them. And if she can't eat them shes not interested in them at all. She has to sleep in a crate because she is extremely destructive and will eat the walls and floor. She sleeps in a separate room because I'm a light sleeper and cant deal with the shuffling of having her in my room. We have tried having her in the same room and different rooms than the other dog, who is also crated for anxiety. She socializes with us all day but as soon as we lock her up for the night she barks. Non-stop for hours and hours. She paces her self. 1 quick bark every 5 seconds so she never gets tired. I'm losing my mind. She doesn't care about the sound boxes. She doesnt care about being shot with water. What do I do?

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Sadie, First, teach Rose the "Quiet" command using the "Quiet" method from the article that I have linked below. https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Once she understands what the word means and can stop barking while outside of the crate at other times, then check out Jeff Gelhman's Separation Anxiety protocol from the link below. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5GqzeLzysk When you put your dog into the crate tell her "Quiet" and then follow Jeff's protocol from the video when she starts to bark. Jeff's protocol will involve correction but the point of it is to communicate to the dog and interrupt the anxious state of mind. It is done in a fair and well communicated way. Jeff can sound a little harsh and blunt on his videos but his training is very effective for anxious, rude, or demanding dogs. His type of training is not necessary for all dogs but dogs who are being demanding, struggling to be alone, have anxiety, or are generally just rude tend to need more structure and firmness, at least for a while, and he does train with structure and fair firmness. The video is a bit long but watch the whole thing. A text summary of the video to go back to for reference can be found here: https://www.solidk9training.com/sk9-blog/2013/02/21/separation-anxiety-im-not-seeing-it-at-my-place Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Rose's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Sid
Border Terrier
7 Years
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Sid
Border Terrier
7 Years

Although he is fine when when left in the house usually with a stuffed Kong he barks when left in the car initially but is quiet when we return even though he still gets a chew stick.Also when we try to take him to a public place ie the pub or public transport he is the same gets bored and barks so we tend to avoid taking him to public places but really would like to take him sometimes.
How can we rectify this situation without anoying other people?
Marlene

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Marene, Because the car issue is happening when you are gone, you will need something that can correct him from a distance. First, spend time teaching him the "Quiet" command by using the "Quiet" method from the article that I have linked below. https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Once he can respond to your "Quiet" command consistently at home when you knock or do other things to encourage him to bark, then take him to public places where he will not be too much of a nuisance but will still bark, like the park. Practice the "Quiet" command there. If he obeys, then reward him. Also reward him for staying quiet for five to ten minutes. If he disobeys, then correct him with an air canister, called a "Pet Convincer", aimed at his side, not his face. Tell him "Ah Ah" and release one quick puff of air toward his side to surprise him. When he gets quiet again and stays quiet for at least three to five minutes, then reward his quiet behavior with a treat so that he will learn that quietness is rewarded, and barking is corrected. Practice this until he will be quiet while with you in public. As he improves, then gradually increase how long you expect him to be quiet for before you give him a treat. A Pet Convincer is simply a small pressured canister of air that can be purchased online, on places like Amazon. https://www.amazon.com/PRO-EQUIPMENT-Pet-Convincer-Training/dp/B00JL16HSS/ref=sr_1_3?s=pet-supplies&ie=UTF8&qid=1537746151&sr=1-3&keywords=pet+convincer When Sid is in the car alone, has learned the meaning of the "Quiet" command, and has learned to be quiet while with you out in public, then leave him alone in the car while it is cool outside with the windows cracked enough for you to reach inside but not for him to be able to get his head out. Command him to be "Quiet" when you leave. Hide somewhere very close-by, like behind a tree in front of the car. Wait until he barks, and when he does tell him "Ah Ah" loudly enough for him to hear you from where you are. If he barks again, then repeat your "Ah-Ah" correction and go over to the car, reach inside, and correct him with a puff of air. You can also purchase an automatic air dispensing collar that will correct him for you when he barks. Do NOT purchase the citronella one, or if you do buy the unscented air replacements and switch out the unscented air. Use only unscented air for this. The citronella is very strong for a dog's sensitive sense of smell and can linger for a very long time for a dog and continue to correct him long after he stops the behavior. When he barks, the collar will automatically correct him or you can purchase one that is controlled with a handheld remote and you can correct him manually. If you are using an automatic one or remote one, then do not return to the car when he barks, but watch him from somewhere hidden to see how he is responding at first. When he becomes quiet and stays quiet for at least five minutes, then return to the car window and pass him treats through the cracked window, remind him to be "Quiet", and walk away again. Practice all of this until he no longer barks when you get out of sight or stay gone, but instead learns to settle down in the car and chew on the chew toy that you gave him or quietly watch out the window. If your dog is remote collar trained with a high quality e-collar, then you can also use the e-collar at his "working level" to correct his barking in place of the air collar and pet corrector, but teach your dog the "Quiet" command first so that he will understand why he is being corrected. Also, be sure to reward his quietness because that will lead to long term results better than corrections alone. Only use an e-collar if you have been properly trained how to use, fit, and train with one. Do not simply go out and purchase a cheap one and start using it. E-collars can be dangerous if used wrong or cheap brands are used. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Sid's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Flash
Rottweiler
3 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Flash
Rottweiler
3 Months

Hello. We recently adopted from an amazing breeder our first rottweiler puppy. She is very smart and very affectionate. We socialize her a lot and she does very well with other dogs and people. She’s confident and we’ve seen a lot of progress in the past 6 weeks. However she’s very clingy. We don’t mind her being close to us but it causes problems when we want to enter another room she’s not allowed in (our bedroom) she will bark and scratch at the door. We have crate trained her and she does good however when we put her in during dinner time for example she started to bark (she would sofly whine before) and will bark pretty much whenever she wants our attention. We are very aware of trying to ignore her but we live in a town house and have neighbors who can definitely hear her and we are scared to bother them so we give in more easily. She also howls when we leave her in her crate and leave the house. She doesn’t try to escape her crate or destroy anything but she’s vocal. We’re not sure if it’s separation anxiety or boredom/attention seeking behavior. We need help! We are also going through the teething phase so we need all the advice we can get. Many thanks!

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Lisanne, If you were able to let her bark and remove all attention, then the attention seeking barking might resolve itself, but since you are in a townhouse, I highly recommend correcting the barking. Doing this correctly in combination with something else I will explain should also help with the howling. First, teach her the meaning of "Quiet" by following the "Quiet" method from the article that I have linked below. https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Second, once she understands what "Quiet" means, then purchase a "Pet Convincer" which is a small canister of pressurized air. When you leave her alone, tell her "Quiet". If he stays quiet for five minutes while you are in the other room, then return to her and drop a couple of treats into the crate, then leave again. Repeat this for thirty-minutes before letting her out of the crate while she is being quiet. When she can handle that, then give the treats less often, every ten-minutes, then every fifteen, every twenty, every thirty-minutes, ect... If she barks when you leave, even after being told "Quiet", then return to her, calmly but firmly tell her "Ah Ah" and spray a puff of air from the Pet Convincer at her side through the crate or baby gate, then tell her "Quiet" again to remind her, and leave again. If she stays quiet for five minutes after you leave, then you can go back and reward her with treats for staying quiet. When you leave her alone in general, give her a food-stuffed hollow chew-toy. She needs something to do while in the crate - especially at this age. You can stuff a large hollow classic Kong toy by putting her dry dog food into a bowl, covering the food with water, letting it sit out until the food turns to mush, then mix a bit of liver paste or peanut butter (NO Xylitol sweetener - it's toxic) into the food mush. Loosely stuff the Kong toy with the mixture, then either give it to her like that or put it into the freezer overnight so that it will help with teething and last longer...If you freeze them, then you can buy several toys, stuff them all at once and freeze them all - so that you can simply grab one from the freezer as needed. Once she gets out of the habit of barking or howling when you are home and is being given something interesting to do in the crate (the stuffed Kong), she will hopefully learn to self-sooth and self-entertain better and will not howl when you are gone. If the howling continues, then you will need to take the training a step further and correct her remotely while watching her on a camera from outside (so that she thinks you have left). You can correct her remotely with a vibration collar, a stimulation collar, an unscented air spray collar (do NOT use citronella or a scented one), or you can use a regular bark collar (preferable with lower level stimulations at this age). A stimulation collar (aka: e-collar/ electric collar/remote training collar) that also has a vibration setting will actually be one of the least unpleasant things to use if you get a good one with at least sixty-levels so that you can correct on the lowest level that she will respond to or on vibration (some dogs consider vibration more of a punishment though because it's a stronger sensation even though it does not hurt at all - so a collar with both will let you see what works best for her). If you end up needing to do this I suggest hiring a trainer to help you in person, or at least hiring someone who can walk you through it while you are doing it - over the phone. You do not want to correct too high, and you want the timing to be right, so that she learns instead of gets upset or frustrated. If done right, it can actually help her not to get into such an anxious state and you can use that calmer window combined with rewards for her calmness, and a Kong to chew on, to teach her how to cope with being alone. Correcting remotely just needs to be done carefully though. Teaching her a "Place" command and working on a "Down-Stay" from a distance are also good exercises for her to practice. Any obedience commands that require her to obey and be further away from you can help with her independence. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Flash's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Talon
Husky
11 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Talon
Husky
11 Months

My dog will not stop barking for attention. He cries and shoves his nose into when I'm eating and he is currently outside my bedroom door barking. I sat down to eat and he started. i put him in the time out corner and made him lay down and stay for 5 minutes about 3 times. The last 2-3 times I increased it to 10 minutes each. He persisted despite rewards when he lay down and was quiet. I rewarded him with treats and a toy. He went for two walks that totaled to over an hour plus play time and training today. He has been fed and watered. My last resort for ignoring is locking myself in my room to ignore him until he stops barking and lays down to occupy himself. He has quieted down since I have been in my room. He does not stop crying and having tantrums in his crate. He has anxiety and I have been working almost every single day in some form or another practicing stay and leaving the room at varying increments and rewarding him after that time if he stayed in his crate with the door open or if he lays down and doesn't cry in that period. I bring him to a park a few times a week that is fenced in. One is a dog park I try to get to every week or two and the other is a fenced in playground.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Lauren, It doesn't sound like exercise is his issue. He needs boundaries and structure, and the barking should be carefully disciplined at this point. I suggest finding a trainer who uses both positive reinforcement and fair corrections and is very experienced with e-collars to help you. Check out Jeff Gellman from SolidK9Training. He has several videos about giving your dog structure and boundaries, working their minds, correcting barking, and even dealing with separation anxiety. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nd0N6fdAoD0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Ka2x-yMSzM&t=31s Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Talon's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Lucky
Labrador Retriever
9 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Lucky
Labrador Retriever
9 Months

My dog has been getting better at doing the "bed" command. I used the leash to hold him at his bed (it has enough slack to extend 3 feet off the blanket i used for him).

During mealtime, I have a camera directed towards him and I view him from my phone. When I see him get off, I tell him "bed" (from the kitchen where he cannot see us), and if he doesn't listen, I walk out to where he sees me.

Sometimes he would just stare at me and not walk to his bed until I walk a few steps closer.

I use the leash and the blanket (the bed) at the same time, since the main purpose of the blanket is for him to stay when we're cooking or eating.

He started barking from his bed, although he does stay on the bed, laying down, looking here and there. The only thing discouraging him from getting up is the leash attached to him. (I put the other end of the leash under a bookshelf.)

I try telling him "quiet", but apparently he doesn't care; he thinks obeying the "bed" command is enough for him.

In the morning, he always barks from his crate. Should I train him out of it, or no? There are two things:

If I don't train him to not bark in the morning, if we forget to take him out to potty, it would remind us.

We rarely forget to take him out in the morning.

If we DO train him out, if this is true, he might potty in the crate instead of asking us to let him out.

We still like to train him out of barking in the morning, and if possible, teach him a way to ask to go out without barking when he is in the crate?

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Kien, Glad to hear that you are making progress. You can teach a "Quiet" command and use that for the barking just when you want him to stop. Check out the article that I have linked below and follow the "Quiet" method for how to teach Quiet. https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark After he knows what Quiet means, then you can discipline disobedience to your command (opposed to all barking) using a hand help remote training device and collar. I suggest purchasing a collar like Garmin Delta with Bark Limiter or SportDog Yard Trainer or e-collar technologies mini educator. You should only ever use a high quality remote training collar, cheap ones online can be dangerous. Look for a collar like one of those that has multiple stimulation levels and a vibration level. Have him wear the collar around for a few days with it turned off to get him used to the feel and so that he won't learn to only listen if the collar is on. When barks after you have told him "Quiet" you can vibrate the collar while telling him "Ah Ah". If he stops barking great! If not switch to stimulation starting on the lowest level and slowly increase the level until he seems to notice the sensation. The barking may not stop instantly but look for signs that he feels the stimulation like scratching, shaking his head, or moving. Stop at that level, and practice correcting him at that level every time that he barks. After a few corrections he should start to realize that barking gets him in trouble and the barking should decrease a bit then (decreasing overall will take more practice). You can vibrate the collar first each time as a warning to give him the chance to stop barking before the stimulation cuts on. Done this way he will receive the lowest possible correction for him to respond obediently, without rewarding him with attention for barking (because you can enforce you "Quiet" command from the other room once he understands - making the training more effective because right now if he barks he gets your attention). Because you are teaching "Quiet" first he should also learn that the correction is for barking disobediently, and that will give him control of whether or not he is corrected...it's his choice. It will also not discipline him for all barking, just barking after he has already been told "Quiet" and is disobeying the command. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Lucky's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Bowline
Golden Retriever
5 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Bowline
Golden Retriever
5 Months

Hello, we have a 5 month old golden retriever puppy. He is an amazing puppy except that he learned (no idea where) to bark at us in the kitchen. He doesn't do this anywhere else in the house. We have tried to ignore him, take him to his bed, wait until he stops barking reward him for being quiet. We are out of ideas! Help please!

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Cooper, I suggest teaching him the Quiet command. After he knows what "Quiet" means, when he stays quiet and doesn't bark at all in the kitchen reward him with a treat placed on the floor in the other room. When he barks tell him "Quiet" and if he continues barking use a Pet Convincer to spray a small puff of air at his side (NOT face) while saying "Ah Ah". Telling him "Ah Ah" at the same time will teach him to listen to that correction even when you do not correct after he learns it. Follow the "Quiet" method from the article linked below. https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Bowline's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Billy
Patterdale Terrier X
6 Years
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Billy
Patterdale Terrier X
6 Years

Constant barker, how to train him to stop barking at the doorbell/postman/people outside etc with the clicker method

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Patricia, Check out the video below on how to Desensitize a dog to bark triggers. General barking: https://youtu.be/Jp_l9C1yT1g Barking at the door: https://youtu.be/DxPrNnulp5s Barking on walks: https://youtu.be/JY7JrteQBOQ Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Billy's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Maverick
Labrador Retriever
6 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Maverick
Labrador Retriever
6 Months

Our puppy is mainly an outside dog, he gets plenty of exercise and attention and gets taken to the dog park 3-4 times a week. When we are sitting down for dinner or sitting to watch some tv he sits by the back door barking at us - we have tried ignorning but can bark up to 25 mins (longer if we left him) and are concerned for our neighbours. When we leave the room he will stop but as soon as we walk back in he starts again.. we sometimes yell at him to tell him to stop and he acts scared when we do but continues to bark.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Jordy, First, his need for human interaction and mental stimulation needs to be addressed through regular training sessions or walks where you practice obedience and heel throughout the walk. Dog parks provide physical exercise but the mental stimulation or human interaction enough. Second, I suggest teaching the Quiet command and rewarding him when he becomes quiet or stays quiet for five minutes while you are visible in to him. Quiet method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Other ideas to trigger barking to teach Speak and Quiet: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-german-shepherd-to-speak After you have done the above so he understands what to do and has the ability to do it, you can correct with a remote vibration collar when he disobeys your Quiet command. Only do this in combination with the above training though or it likely just confuse him. He needs to understand what Quiet means, be rewarded for being quiet, then corrected if he is disobedient (which is understandable for him). Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Maverick's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Harry
Cairn Terrier
10 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Harry
Cairn Terrier
10 Months

really having problems on recall when other dogs are around does not look at me when callin g him

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Stephen, Check out the Reel In method from the article linked below. If your dog already understands what Come means (which is the first thing you have to do - teach them that Come means come here), and if your dog can come in calmer locations, then use the Reel In method and go places where there are other dogs walking around (who won't run up to you) like the park, and practice your recall around other dogs. Do not practice at the dog park though because having a dog leashed inside a dog park can lead to stress and fights. Reel In method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-whippet-to-recall

Add a comment to Harry's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Sadie
Blue heeler / Lab mix
6 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Sadie
Blue heeler / Lab mix
6 Months

Hi! So my Sadie bug is 5 months ,but will be 6 months in less than a week . I've noticed she picks up commands and potty training well ,but she has this nasty habit of nipping,growling ,barking & scratching at my legs when she has to potty . Ive been trying to figure out how to get her to calmly show me ,but I just don't understand why she gets so loud and aggressive . Besides that ,she's a sweet,timid dog. I'm stumped . Why does she act this way ? ( It's only when she has to potty .)

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Samantha, Dogs all come up with their own way of letting you know when they need to go potty. For whatever reason she has learned that doing that gets a response out of you and she doesn't think other things will get the same response. I suggest teaching her to ring a bell instead and making that something rewarding until she has developed a firm habit of doing that whenever she needs to go- then eventually phasing out those treats too when she no longer needs them. Check out the article linked below on teaching a bell. Once she has learned to ring it when you point to the bell, have her ring it when you point to it every time that you take her potty, then reward her with a treat when she goes potty outside after she rang the bell to get out. https://wagwalking.com/training/ring-a-bell-to-go-out Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Sadie's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Gus
Basset Hound
8 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Gus
Basset Hound
8 Months

I know this is an older article but I have had Gus for 6 months now and I have not slept through the night in 6 months!! I love him more than anything and I have tried everything to get the barking to stop. He will literally bark non-stop if I am out of the room and he is in his crate. I have tried the ignoring thing and I am not kidding when I say that he absolutely will not stop. I feel like I can't get anything done because I can't stand to listen to thew barking. He is not to be trusted out loose in the house as he gets into everything and will chew things that don't belong to him. He also still gets me up 2 to 3 times a night. Sometimes he potty's and sometimes he thinks it's play time. He will also bark non stop until I get up, hence the reason I haven't slept good in 6 months. I have tried having him sleep with me but he thinks my bed is a racetrack and will not settle down and go to sleep. I have had to resort to a bark collar and it is the kind that beeps, then vibrates, then a static shock. He knows the pattern by now and he still barks and barks. I don't know what else I can do.... Do you think the quiet method would work for him? I haven't tried that yet however, as soon as I come to the living room where his crate is, he stops barking. He doesn't do the barking while I'm in the room. Any help at this point would be great as I am just so exhausted. Thank you.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Lisa, I suggest using a Pet Convincer (which is a small canister of pressurized, unscented air you can spray - do NOT use citronella - the scent lingers too long, is too harsh, and can be confusing for a dog) in combination with a lot of structure and boundaries during the day to deal with his over all demanding attitude. In general, put him into boot-camp. Make him work for all of his dog food during the day. Use his daily kibble as rewards for his obedience. Teach him Out-which means leave the area, and any time he is nudging you, in your space uninvited, or generally being pushy, tell him out and enforce it. Teach him a Place command and practice him staying on place for up to an hour while you are home - whether you are in the room or not. You want him to learn to stay somewhere because he is choosing to out of obedience and not just because he can't get out - the attitude is different in both cases even though he will obviously still be crated with the door closed at other times. Out: https://www.petful.com/behaviors/how-to-teach-a-dog-the-out-command/ Place: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omg5DVPWIWo Crate Manners: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mn5HTiryZN8 Work on the crate manners protocol linked above for teaching him how to go in and out of the crate and stay in the crate with the door open until released - similar to Place, he is having to choose to obey which is a good exercise to deal with the attitude. When you walk him, walks should be structured heeling. He should be working during walks by heeling, focusing on you, and stopping and sitting when you stop. Practicing those commands and rules will help him learn the skills he needs to be calm in the crate and stop the demanding attitude. It doesn't sound like he has separation anxiety - it sounds like he is demanding that you free him because he is bored. Heel article - The turns method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-poodle-to-heel Heel Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTiKVc4ZZWo In combination with the exercises mentioned above, teach him what Quiet means. Quiet method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark When you put him into the crate, tell him Quiet. Put his crate somewhere where you can appear and correct quickly so that your correction is timed more closely to his barking, like against a wall where you can be just around the corner on the other side of that wall and him not see you until you are there to correct or reward - this way he doesn't have the chance to stop his barking much before the correction because he saw you, and the correction happens close to his barking timing-wise. If he barks, calmly walk back into the room, over to his crate, and spray a puff of unscented air from the Pet Convincer at his side through the crate while saying "Ah Ah" calmly (NOT at his face). Repeat your quiet command calmly after correcting, then leave again. If he stays quiet this time, return after five minutes and sprinkle dog food into his crate as a reward, then leave again. Every time he barks, return and correct with the Pet Convincer, and whenever he stays quiet, return and reward. As he improves, wait until he is wait for a longer periods of time before you reward him. Five minutes, then 8 minutes, then 10 minutes, then 15 minutes, then 25 minutes, ect...Until he is quiet the whole time he is crated. Pet Convincer example, can also be purchased other places: https://www.amazon.com/PRO-EQUIPMENT-Pet-Convincer-Training/dp/B00JL16HSS/ref=asc_df_B00JL16HSS/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=241991316466&hvpos=1o13&hvnetw=g&hvrand=9410007087252192433&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9010791&hvtargid=aud-643565131866:pla-402082951148&psc=1 The success of this will depend partially on whether you implement the other training mentioned to address his pushiness and attitude, so don't overlook that part. You may find that the other training helps with listening and other potential behavior problems too as a bonus. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Gus's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Buttercup
American Eskimo Dog
11 Years
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Buttercup
American Eskimo Dog
11 Years

I've worked hard over the years with Buttercup on obedience. She's generally well-behaved and even knows some tricks. But her barking has always been a problem that I've had a lot of trouble training. She barks at the door, and passersby and squirrels out the window, etc. I know Eskies can want to be watch dogs, I accept a certain amount, but I wanted to train her to have something else to do when she's barking, and generally deescalate.

I recently decided to use the Quiet Method, very similar to what's outlined on your site. However, she seems to have learned that if she barks, she will get me to Quiet her, and she gets a treat. Her barking is worse than ever. Now she will ignore the window altogether and simply sit next to me and bark in a very high-pitched, almost conversational way, trying different sounds to get me to Quiet her and reward her. As soon as I do, she starts barking again. This is getting a little crazy and she seems to get very worked up trying to get a treat. What do you suggest to break this accidental habit I created?

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Megan, I suggest two things. First, require more before giving her a treat. So say quiet, and wait ten seconds before giving a treat, then require one minute of quiet before a treat, then five minutes of quiet before a treat, then ten minutes before a treat, ect...The goal should be her getting rewarded for STAYING quiet, not just getting quiet once she understands what the Quiet word means - which she does now. Second, correct the barking. It is okay to use a punisher for the demanding barking - that behavior is not fear based or an inability to be quiet - she is being pushy. I suggest purchasing a Pet Convincer - which is a small canister of unscented pressurized air. When she barks, tell her Quiet and WAIT. If she stays quiet for several minutes, you can reward with a treat (require quietness for longer and longer before giving the treat the more you practice this, until you work up to over an hour of quietness before giving a treat). If she barks during the waiting period, spray a small puff of air at her side (not her face) with the pet convincer while calmly saying "Ah Ah" to let her know that behavior was wrong. The spray should surprise her enough to stop the barking and probably make her walk away from you and stop being pushy. When doing it this way she should clearly understand from your Quiet command that she is supposed to be quiet, and the correction is for disobeying a command that she knows - her being demanding, so she has control of whether she is corrected or not because she knows why. After you correct you can remind her to be Quiet again, and reset the time in your head, wait several minutes and if she stays quiet for several minutes this time, reward with a treat - if she barks again during that time, correct again, and repeat the entire process until she leaves you alone or stays quiet near you. Once you have dealt with the barking for treats, then when she barks at the window, tell her Quiet. If she gets quiet and stays quiet, reward after a bit. If she continues barking or stops and starts again right away, correct with the pet convincer. Its very important to correct the barking as soon as it starts because certain chemicals are released in a dog's brain when they bark that further encourages the barking and gets them highly aroused. It is much harder to get a dog to stop and calm back down after they have been barking for a bit than when they first begin. To deal with the over sensitivity to things in the first place, you can begin to reward calmness and quietness around those things BEFORE she barks and gets excited - to condition her to stay in that calmer mindset around those triggers. When she starts to get worked up (even before barking), tell her "Ah Ah" and if that alone isn't effective and calming her back down, give a mild correction to snap her out of her aroused mindset before she starts getting really worked up. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Buttercup's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Maddie
Mini labradoodle
9 Months
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Maddie
Mini labradoodle
9 Months

Hi there, our gorgeous pup has been so well behaved until about 6 weeks ago and now she is driving me crazy late afternoon / evening with attention seeking barking.

I work from home and work upstairs in a little study. For the first couple of months we had quite a nice routine, she would stay in the play pen down stairs and I would go and see her every couple of hours and have a little play then leave her again. We tended to for our walk around 4pm as she slept a lot of the day. Post 4 she was very restless so I brought out kongs, Licki mats etc, things I read so she coold entertain herself while I finished up my work..not all successful.

Then circumstances changed, my husband was redundant for 3 months and so my pup had one or both of us around for a lot of the time and got lots of attention. S We also had a couple of holidays with family and she had company and attention all the time then too.

Now my husband is back at work and its just me and the pup again. I no longer confine her to the kitchen as while my husband was off she was growing up and we felt no longer needed the pen or that restriction. What tends to happen now is she sleeps most of the morning anywhere in the house without a peep (which I know is great) and then at lunch time I go and see her, have a play and take her for her first walk. She then tends to sleep more in the afternoon but by 4.30 she's very much ready for attention. I think that's fair enough after so much sleeping so then I take her for another walk, a bit longer then have a little play. The problem I am having is that it is then expected that i entertain her from that time until about 9pm when she finally settles down. If I sit and try and finish up work she constantly barks at me, if I ignore that she starts ripping at the carpet or biting my chair or doing something destructive! I then stop that but if I ever sit and relax ie watch tv she barks at me again..its constant. I've tried my old tricks such as kongs but she's not that interested.

I know I'm lucky she's good for so much of the day but it's exhausted from 4.30- 9 and I don't know what I'm doing wrong. Any help really welcomed. Thanks!!!

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Laura, First, I would actually switch what you are doing to exercise her at 4 pm (keep the other walks). Instead of spending 30-45 minutes taking her for a walk at that time, I suggest having a training session where she has to really concentrate and use a lot of self-control. Practicing things like "Sit, Down, Stand" over and over, switching up the order so she really has to listen to which one you said (teach all three so she can't just guess). Practice Heel or come in your neighborhood using a long leash - around gradually harder and harder distractions as she improves so it's more difficult. Practice a long Place command around lots of distractions (start easy and work up to distractions). Distractions may start with you walking away, then you dropping objects where she can see, then kids running around, then ringing your doorbell, ect...Teach Quiet and Out during some of the sessions (which also help with the pushiness). It will take time and practice to teach her commands but if you just use the normal walk time to train instead the training should accomplish a few things: 1. Earn more of her respect so that she is less demanding and pushy with you in general. 2. Stimulate her mentally - which has been proven to be twice as tiring for a dog than physical exercise alone, and can have a calming effect...Many dogs fall asleep after a hard training session. 3. Teach behaviors that directly help you deal with the behavior...Quiet, Out, and Place. 4. Improve your relationship with her. 5. Help her develop calmness and impulse control to learn to self-regulate better. Sit: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-german-shepherd-puppy-to-sit Down: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-german-shepherd-to-lay-down Stay: https://www.thelabradorsite.com/train-your-labrador-to-lie-down-and-stay/ Stand: https://wagwalking.com/training/stand-and-stay Come - The Reel In method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-whippet-to-recall Heel article - The turns method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-poodle-to-heel Heel Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTiKVc4ZZWo Place: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omg5DVPWIWo Out: https://www.petful.com/behaviors/how-to-teach-a-dog-the-out-command/ Quiet- The Quiet method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark The above mental stimulate is what I would ultimately focus on to meet the need for more respect, mental stimulation, and communication. Focus on that as your ultimate, long term goal. For the short term, teach the Quiet command. When he barks, tell him "Quiet" calmly one time. If he continues barking after being told Quiet, spray a small puff of unscented air from a Pet Convincer at his side while saying "Ah Ah" calmly - this is to correct the demanding attitude and surprise him a bit to create quietness. Continue to provide a food stuffed chew toy at that time since he will be more likely to start chewing on that again once calmer again and will need something to do. If he starts to get destructive after doing the above at that point, send him to Place or confine him in the crate or exercise pen. Ultimately if you starting doing a training session at that time (even if you only have 10 minutes) that should help with his pent up energy and frustration that is the real issue. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Maddie's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Rosie
Bichon Frise
2 Years
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Rosie
Bichon Frise
2 Years

Rosie has started to bark when put into her crate at bedtime. I have tried the collar on her that makes a noise when she barks does nothing for her. She has a piercing bark that is hard to ignore. I know she is wanting to come upstairs to my bedroom but I don’t want to start that habit. Can you give me some advice.

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Ina, If the protests are just her acting demanding, you have two options. You can ignore the crying until she gives up and realizes after a few days that it doesn't get her out of the crate - so she stops, OR you can discipline the crying - at this point I suggest correcting it using fair discipline. To discipline the barking, start by teaching the Quiet command using the Quiet method from the article linked below. Quiet method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Practice the Quiet command method during the day until she learns the meaning of the word quiet. Since you want her to learn it quickly, I suggest practicing for a few minutes several times per day to speed up learning. Only give treats while practicing this during the day - no treats at night. Once she understands Quiet, if she barks in the crate and it has been less than 8 hours since she last went potty (I am assuming you take her potty right before crating her), then when she cries tell her "Quiet". If she gets quiet - great! Go back to bed, nothing else happens. If she doesn't get quiet or starts barking again right away, calmly say "Ah Ah" and use a small canister of pressurized air, called a Pet Convincer, to spray a quick puff of unscented air (do NOT use citronella) at her side through the crate's wires (avoid spraying her in the face). After spraying her, leave. Repeat the corrections each time she barks until she goes to sleep. This can also be done using a remote training collar with stimulation on a her "working level". I don't recommend sound or citronella. If you decide to use a remote training collar, I suggest hiring a trainer to help you with that, since remote training collars are powerful tools that need to be fitted correctly, set on the right level for YOUR dog, timed well, combined with the right training, and a high quality, safe brand. A Pet Conviner is a simpler tool so that may be easier to try first - just don't use citronella or scented types and avoid her face when you spray it. Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Rosie's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Question
Jet
Staffordshire Bull Terrier
5 Years
0 found helpful
Question
0 found helpful
Jet
Staffordshire Bull Terrier
5 Years

Hi,
Our Staffy barks outside downstairs to get my attention. Not so much my husband's attention but mine. She came to us when she was 3 years old, re-homed. We have been using a citronella spray collar but that does not seem to be working with her any more. It's spraying when she's barking and she continues to bark! More recently when she barks I've been directing her into her crate (the one she grew up with as a puppy) and we have 'time out' in the crate. I lure her in there with a treat. She does not incessantly bark and does not bark inside or at night. We walk her twice a day 3 days a week and 1 big walk the other 4 days. We throw balls with her at the end of most days and she has toys and a tug rope. It seems she is obsessed with wanting me to play with her and barks to get my attention. I know Staffy's are high energy, needy and anxious, loveable and loyal. She does test our patience and our neighbours.
What to do??

Caitlin Crittenden
Caitlin Crittenden
Dog Trainer
463 Dog owners recommended

Hello Josie, Unfortunately because the citronella smell can linger for so long for a dog with a sensitive nose - citronella sprays can actually be very confusing and thus ineffective. They do deter barking at first but the dog is essentially corrected for barking, but since the smell doesn't stop when the dog gets quiet the dog also continues to be corrected for being quiet. When the dog is corrected for barking and for being quiet there is little motivation for the dog to be quiet and not bark. With all that said, I suggest switching to a stimulation based bark collar - a good one is actually more humane than citronella because the correction is instantaneous and stops as soon as the barking stops. You need to teach the dog why they are being corrected first though. Teach the Quiet command from the article linked below. https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bark Once pup knows Quiet, practice it in real life scenarios when pup barks at things like walkers, cats, or the doorbell. After a bit of practice, add the bark collar. Have pup wear the bark collar around for a couple of days when you are home with it turned off before training with it on - so that pup won't learn to only be quiet when the collar is on, but will view the collar as a neutral thing. Whenever there is a barking trigger, like the doorbell ringing or a walker that pup spots, tell pup "Quiet", then if pup disobeys and barks they will be corrected automatically with the collar. If pup stays quiet, praise calmly and give a treat. Practice this until pup clearly associates the correction with their barking and not just the people or noise they are barking at or thinking the corrections are random. Its important to include the treats for quiet behavior around the barking triggers also, so that pup sees that doorbells ringing or people passing don't equal corrections only barking at the doorbell or people/cats, ect... Once pup understands that they should be quiet from being rewarded, and not to bark from being corrected, let pup wear the bark collar during times when he tends to bark for your attention. If he barks, the collar should correct him and he should remember the barking lesson and know how to stop the corrections by getting quiet on his own. Along with the barking specific training I highly suggest adding in some mental stimulation through other training practice to build his respect for you, his self-control, and his overall confidence. Exercise is important and needed but it doesn't always equal calm for a dog with a lot of endurance - mental stimulation by way of training slightly challenging things tends to help with respect and calmness more. Bellow are some good commands to practice with pup to help with the overall attitude. I would suggest having short training sessions with pup several times a week, or incorporating commands into pup's day, even if that means only giving one walk and doing one 20 minute training session in place of the second walk. Place: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omg5DVPWIWo Crate manners: https://thegooddog.net/training-videos/free-how-to-training-videos/learn-to-train-the-good-dog-way-the-crate/ Out command: https://www.petful.com/behaviors/how-to-teach-a-dog-the-out-command/ Thresholds: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-w28C2g68M Heel article - The turns method: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-poodle-to-heel Heel Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTiKVc4ZZWo Working and Consistency methods: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-doberman-to-listen-to-you Leave It method for leave it command: https://wagwalking.com/training/train-a-shih-tzu-puppy-to-not-bite Best of luck training, Caitlin Crittenden

Add a comment to Jet's experience

Was this experience helpful?

Book me a walkiee?
Pweeeze!
Sketch of smiling australian shepherd